A friend of mine has been very into cooking in muffin tins lately. She’s made meatloaf cupcakes, lasagna and enchiladas. Using muffin tins for other things is a great idea for a lot of reasons including monitoring portion size, but my favourite is you get more crispy edges.
When I was talking to this friend one day recently and she was making chicken pot pie I had the lightbulb moment of making chicken pot pie in muffin tins. Every pot pie recipe has a different take on if the crust should be on the top or the bottom or both. If you couldn’t tell, I want crust all around.
A muffin pan filled with mini pot pies. Yum.
Please note the filling has to cool before being put into the crust, so consider that in your timeline.
This recipe makes a lot of mini pies (24 to be exact), but they freeze really well and so are great for lunches (especially if your office has a toaster oven) or just something yummy in the freezer.
Mini chicken pot pies
Makes 24 muffin size pies
1.5 Tbsp butter
1/2 onion finely chopped
3 cloves of garlic finely chopped
3/4 cup celery chopped
1 cup carrots (about 3 carrots) chopped
1 Tbsp dried sage (or about 1/4 cup chopped fresh sage)
1 tsp dried thyme (or about 2 Tbsp fresh thyme)
4 cups swiss chard finely chopped (spinach or kale would work)
1/4 cup flat leaf parsley chopped
2 cups mushrooms chopped (optional)
2 cups chicken (about 3 large breasts) chopped
2 Tbsp butter
2 Tbsp (approx) flour plus a little more for dusting chicken
3 cups (approx) chicken stock*
Puff pastry – package with two sheets, defrosted
1 egg
-In a large saucepan, heat 1 Tbsp butter with garlic, onion, celery carrots and sage over medium heat and saute until veggies are starting to soften. Add in the mushrooms if using and cook for 2 minutes – season with salt/pepper.
-Add the chard, parsley and thyme and a splash of chicken stock. Cook until the chard has wilted to half its size. Put all the veggies in a bowl and set aside.
-Dust the chopped chicken in flour just to coat it. Put another 1/2 Tbsp butter in the saucepan, once melted increase to medium-high heat and add the chicken. Season with salt and pepper. Cook, stirring frequently, until browned and mostly cooked. Then add to bowl with veggies.
-Reduce heat to medium (you may need to take the pot off the burner for a couple of minutes) and add 2 Tbsp of butter, once melted add in 2 Tbsp of flour while stirring to combine and prevent sticking. Cook butter and flour for about a minute.
-Slowly start adding the chicken stock. Stir or whisk while adding the liquid so everything is evenly combined. Start with about 1/4 cup, once first round of liquid is thick (it won’t take long) add about a 1/2 cup and do the same. Slowly add the stock as the gravy thickens. You may not need a full 3 cups of stock, or you may need more. You want it to be about the consistency of gravy. (If the gravy isn’t thickening combine equal parts flour and stock or water in a jar or bowl and mix to combine and add it into the gravy, bring to a boil and it should thicken after a few minutes)
-Once gravy is thickened add the chicken and veggies back in, simmer until chicken is cooked. Taste for seasoning, add more salt/pepper as needed. Let cool for at least 30 minutes, or overnight.
-Heat oven to 375 degrees. Lightly spray muffin tins with cooking spray (unless you know they’re super non-stick).
-Roll out the puff pastry slightly, not so thin you can see the counter, but enough to get 12 squares/rectangles out of each sheet.
-Place the pieces of pastry into the muffin cup and gently press to the shape of the cup. There will be excess pastry, which will be folded over the filling to make the topping.
-Add in about a 1/3 a cup of filling to each cup. Fold over the excess pastry. The tops may not be perfectly covered and that’s OK.
-In a small bowl mix up the egg with a splash of water. Use a pastry brush and lightly coat the pastry.
-Bake for 25-40 minutes until tops are lightly brown.
NOTE: You could replace the puff pastry with pie crust if you prefer… You could also use the filling for a full-size pie, but it would be less fun.